Lemming Train - How is this still a thing?

Download
First things first, I don't have anything against lemming trains or lone wolf players. It all comes down to how these are executed.
In this replay there is a nice lemming train (9 ships + CV support) which gets stalled and slowly eliminated because no one wants to be the one to aggressively push and being shot at. You can easily make a 3x3 squares area (at times even smaller) and find all the ships sailing around in there. At the same time the enemy team just sails around the other side of the map and straight into our cap. That's not how it is supposed to be executed as far as I know...

Thx to our Benson for providing some nice smoke, that was really appreciated by me, and trying to get rid of the enemy DD in cap. At least the Benson had the "Situational awareness" skill equiped and made use of it the best he could.

youtube link will be added
  • commentReactions
  • perm_mediaBattle Result Images
    Battle Results Image
    Battle Results Image
    Battle Results Image
    Battle Results Image
  • video_libraryVideo
  • classAchievements
    Close Quarters Expert
  • pageviewBattle Details
    Player:
    SubaruSama
    Ship:
    Bismarck
    Map:
    Estuary
    Results:
    DEFEAT!
    Duration:
    0:14:14
    Game Mode:
    StandDom
    Players:
    12 vs 12
    Date Played:
    19.05.2017
    Downloads:
    2
    Views:
    21
    Game Version:
    0, 6, 5, 250745
  • assessmentMatchmaking Analysis
    Class Friendly Enemy
    Carrier 1 1
    Battleships 5 5
    Cruisers 4 5
    Destroyers 2 1
    Tier Friendly Enemy
    Tier VIII 10 10
    Tier VII 0 1
    Tier VI 2 1
    Class Friendly Enemy
    Carrier 104 102
    Battleship 90.4 99.6
    Cruiser 95.75 99
    Destroyer 86 166
    Class Tier VIII Tier VII Tier VI
    Carrier 1 vs 1 0 vs 0 0 vs 0
    Battleship 5 vs 5 0 vs 0 0 vs 0
    Cruiser 3 vs 3 0 vs 1 1 vs 1
    Destroyer 1 vs 1 0 vs 0 1 vs 0
  • hearingSharing
  • recent_actorsTeams
    • Friendly Team
    • ukodlak in the Tier VIII Lexington
      Ship Stats Overall Stats
      Ship Rating: 104  
      Ship Battles: 80 Overall Battles: 1859
      Ship Frags: 58 Overall Frags: 961
      Ship Win Rate: 53.75% Overall Win Rate: 47.71%
      Ship Avg Frags: .73 Overall Avg Frags: .52
      Ship Wins: 43 Overall Wins: 887
      Ship Max Frags: 3 Overall Max Frags: 6
      Ship Max Damage: 136652 Aggression: 15
    • Halking in the Tier VIII Amagi
      Ship Stats Overall Stats
      Ship Rating: 68  
      Ship Battles: 33 Overall Battles: 5005
      Ship Frags: 8 Overall Frags: 1571
      Ship Win Rate: 48.48% Overall Win Rate: 44.94%
      Ship Avg Frags: .24 Overall Avg Frags: .31
      Ship Wins: 16 Overall Wins: 2249
      Ship Max Frags: 2 Overall Max Frags: 5
      Ship Max Damage: 103549 Aggression: 20
    • Cichy_R in the Tier VIII North Carolina
      Ship Stats Overall Stats
      Ship Rating: 116  
      Ship Battles: 586 Overall Battles: 6343
      Ship Frags: 644 Overall Frags: 6445
      Ship Win Rate: 50.51% Overall Win Rate: 50.56%
      Ship Avg Frags: 1.1 Overall Avg Frags: 1.02
      Ship Wins: 296 Overall Wins: 3207
      Ship Max Frags: 6 Overall Max Frags: 7
      Ship Max Damage: 188531 Aggression: 80
    • Thorwin66 in the Tier VIII Tirpitz
      Ship Stats Overall Stats
      Ship Rating: 110  
      Ship Battles: 424 Overall Battles: 5110
      Ship Frags: 364 Overall Frags: 4528
      Ship Win Rate: 46.23% Overall Win Rate: 50.12%
      Ship Avg Frags: .86 Overall Avg Frags: .89
      Ship Wins: 196 Overall Wins: 2561
      Ship Max Frags: 4 Overall Max Frags: 7
      Ship Max Damage: 150972 Aggression: 79
    • SubaruSama in the Tier VIII Bismarck
      Ship Stats Overall Stats
      Ship Rating: 117  
      Ship Battles: 108 Overall Battles: 1404
      Ship Frags: 107 Overall Frags: 1510
      Ship Win Rate: 49.07% Overall Win Rate: 56.34%
      Ship Avg Frags: .99 Overall Avg Frags: 1.08
      Ship Wins: 53 Overall Wins: 791
      Ship Max Frags: 4 Overall Max Frags: 6
      Ship Max Damage: 179777 Aggression: 84
    • AdmiralGrafSpee_1 in the Tier VIII Bismarck
      Ship Stats Overall Stats
      Ship Rating: 41  
      Ship Battles: 169 Overall Battles: 1852
      Ship Frags: 51 Overall Frags: 520
      Ship Win Rate: 38.46% Overall Win Rate: 44.92%
      Ship Avg Frags: .3 Overall Avg Frags: .28
      Ship Wins: 65 Overall Wins: 832
      Ship Max Frags: 3 Overall Max Frags: 5
      Ship Max Damage: 109006 Aggression: 51
    • Laker18 in the Tier VIII Edinburgh
      Ship Stats Overall Stats
      Ship Rating: 46  
      Ship Battles: 167 Overall Battles: 997
      Ship Frags: 55 Overall Frags: 403
      Ship Win Rate: 37.72% Overall Win Rate: 42.63%
      Ship Avg Frags: .33 Overall Avg Frags: .4
      Ship Wins: 63 Overall Wins: 425
      Ship Max Frags: 3 Overall Max Frags: 4
      Ship Max Damage: 78644 Aggression: 53
    • CallicoJackRackham in the Tier VIII Chapayev
      Ship Stats Overall Stats
      Ship Rating: 86  
      Ship Battles: 124 Overall Battles: 2020
      Ship Frags: 85 Overall Frags: 1299
      Ship Win Rate: 48.39% Overall Win Rate: 48.71%
      Ship Avg Frags: .69 Overall Avg Frags: .64
      Ship Wins: 60 Overall Wins: 984
      Ship Max Frags: 4 Overall Max Frags: 5
      Ship Max Damage: 134080 Aggression: 65
    • Irmin42 in the Tier VIII Mogami
      Ship Stats Overall Stats
      Ship Rating: 117  
      Ship Battles: 85 Overall Battles: 2268
      Ship Frags: 55 Overall Frags: 1565
      Ship Win Rate: 61.18% Overall Win Rate: 48.5%
      Ship Avg Frags: .65 Overall Avg Frags: .69
      Ship Wins: 52 Overall Wins: 1100
      Ship Max Frags: 3 Overall Max Frags: 7
      Ship Max Damage: 131669 Aggression: 62
    • N4jin in the Tier VI Budyonny
      Ship Stats Overall Stats
      Ship Rating: 134  
      Ship Battles: 45 Overall Battles: 2922
      Ship Frags: 43 Overall Frags: 2394
      Ship Win Rate: 55.56% Overall Win Rate: 51.98%
      Ship Avg Frags: .96 Overall Avg Frags: .82
      Ship Wins: 25 Overall Wins: 1519
      Ship Max Frags: 3 Overall Max Frags: 5
      Ship Max Damage: 104655 Aggression: 68
    • Magnumenforce in the Tier VIII Benson
      Ship Stats Overall Stats
      Ship Rating: 69  
      Ship Battles: 54 Overall Battles: 989
      Ship Frags: 17 Overall Frags: 417
      Ship Win Rate: 35.19% Overall Win Rate: 46.21%
      Ship Avg Frags: .31 Overall Avg Frags: .42
      Ship Wins: 19 Overall Wins: 457
      Ship Max Frags: 2 Overall Max Frags: 4
      Ship Max Damage: 74082 Aggression: 58
    • davidtuga in the Tier VI Shinonome
      Ship Stats Overall Stats
      Ship Rating: 103  
      Ship Battles: 67 Overall Battles: 2006
      Ship Frags: 57 Overall Frags: 1849
      Ship Win Rate: 52.24% Overall Win Rate: 50.35%
      Ship Avg Frags: .85 Overall Avg Frags: .92
      Ship Wins: 35 Overall Wins: 1010
      Ship Max Frags: 5 Overall Max Frags: 6
      Ship Max Damage: 109140 Aggression: 65
    • Enemy Team
    • Junio_V_B in the Tier VIII Shokaku
      Ship Stats Overall Stats
      Ship Rating: 102  
      Ship Battles: 201 Overall Battles: 8815
      Ship Frags: 228 Overall Frags: 7288
      Ship Win Rate: 61.69% Overall Win Rate: 53.03%
      Ship Avg Frags: 1.13 Overall Avg Frags: .83
      Ship Wins: 124 Overall Wins: 4675
      Ship Max Frags: 4 Overall Max Frags: 8
      Ship Max Damage: 145926 Aggression: 16
    • Pacific_Crown in the Tier VIII Amagi
      Ship Stats Overall Stats
      Ship Rating: 68  
      Ship Battles: 43 Overall Battles: 1917
      Ship Frags: 20 Overall Frags: 980
      Ship Win Rate: 39.53% Overall Win Rate: 50.5%
      Ship Avg Frags: .47 Overall Avg Frags: .51
      Ship Wins: 17 Overall Wins: 968
      Ship Max Frags: 3 Overall Max Frags: 5
      Ship Max Damage: 125789 Aggression: 51
    • barb0ssa in the Tier VIII Amagi
      Ship Stats Overall Stats
      Ship Rating: 117  
      Ship Battles: 59 Overall Battles: 1543
      Ship Frags: 62 Overall Frags: 1179
      Ship Win Rate: 61.02% Overall Win Rate: 50.42%
      Ship Avg Frags: 1.05 Overall Avg Frags: .76
      Ship Wins: 36 Overall Wins: 778
      Ship Max Frags: 6 Overall Max Frags: 8
      Ship Max Damage: 148262 Aggression: 56
    • Pladde in the Tier VIII North Carolina
      Ship Stats Overall Stats
      Ship Rating: 119  
      Ship Battles: 92 Overall Battles: 7121
      Ship Frags: 68 Overall Frags: 4540
      Ship Win Rate: 56.52% Overall Win Rate: 49.12%
      Ship Avg Frags: .74 Overall Avg Frags: .64
      Ship Wins: 52 Overall Wins: 3498
      Ship Max Frags: 3 Overall Max Frags: 7
      Ship Max Damage: 162799 Aggression: 48
    • Qamufel in the Tier VIII Tirpitz
      Ship Stats Overall Stats
      Ship Rating: 126  
      Ship Battles: 28 Overall Battles: 1641
      Ship Frags: 33 Overall Frags: 1168
      Ship Win Rate: 46.43% Overall Win Rate: 49.54%
      Ship Avg Frags: 1.18 Overall Avg Frags: .71
      Ship Wins: 13 Overall Wins: 813
      Ship Max Frags: 4 Overall Max Frags: 6
      Ship Max Damage: 149057 Aggression: 98
    • Lord_Sank4 in the Tier VIII Bismarck
      Ship Stats Overall Stats
      Ship Rating: 68  
      Ship Battles: 38 Overall Battles: 967
      Ship Frags: 24 Overall Frags: 557
      Ship Win Rate: 44.74% Overall Win Rate: 46.23%
      Ship Avg Frags: .63 Overall Avg Frags: .58
      Ship Wins: 17 Overall Wins: 447
      Ship Max Frags: 3 Overall Max Frags: 5
      Ship Max Damage: 91179 Aggression: 45
    • zodpoc39 in the Tier VIII ARP Takao
      Ship Stats Overall Stats
      Ship Rating: 122  
      Ship Battles: 70 Overall Battles: 2248
      Ship Frags: 67 Overall Frags: 1966
      Ship Win Rate: 57.14% Overall Win Rate: 53.2%
      Ship Avg Frags: .96 Overall Avg Frags: .87
      Ship Wins: 40 Overall Wins: 1196
      Ship Max Frags: 4 Overall Max Frags: 6
      Ship Max Damage: 104969 Aggression: 68
    • Shorkann in the Tier VIII Mikhail Kutuzov
      Ship Stats Overall Stats
      Ship Rating: 76  
      Ship Battles: 182 Overall Battles: 4604
      Ship Frags: 88 Overall Frags: 2570
      Ship Win Rate: 47.25% Overall Win Rate: 47.55%
      Ship Avg Frags: .48 Overall Avg Frags: .56
      Ship Wins: 86 Overall Wins: 2189
      Ship Max Frags: 4 Overall Max Frags: 5
      Ship Max Damage: 130266 Aggression: 43
    • Asanur in the Tier VIII New Orleans
      Ship Stats Overall Stats
      Ship Rating: 76  
      Ship Battles: 105 Overall Battles: 710
      Ship Frags: 38 Overall Frags: 388
      Ship Win Rate: 46.67% Overall Win Rate: 47.04%
      Ship Avg Frags: .36 Overall Avg Frags: .55
      Ship Wins: 49 Overall Wins: 334
      Ship Max Frags: 2 Overall Max Frags: 4
      Ship Max Damage: 59440 Aggression: 51
    • drha3011 in the Tier VII Yorck
      Ship Stats Overall Stats
      Ship Rating: 54  
      Ship Battles: 50 Overall Battles: 2551
      Ship Frags: 15 Overall Frags: 1174
      Ship Win Rate: 44% Overall Win Rate: 47.28%
      Ship Avg Frags: .3 Overall Avg Frags: .46
      Ship Wins: 22 Overall Wins: 1206
      Ship Max Frags: 2 Overall Max Frags: 5
      Ship Max Damage: 49695 Aggression: 48
    • dante59 in the Tier VI La Galissonnière
      Ship Stats Overall Stats
      Ship Rating: 167  
      Ship Battles: 21 Overall Battles: 6668
      Ship Frags: 18 Overall Frags: 5270
      Ship Win Rate: 61.9% Overall Win Rate: 50.34%
      Ship Avg Frags: .86 Overall Avg Frags: .79
      Ship Wins: 13 Overall Wins: 3357
      Ship Max Frags: 4 Overall Max Frags: 6
      Ship Max Damage: 95660 Aggression: 80
    • H5703 in the Tier VIII Nowaki
      Ship Stats Overall Stats
      Ship Rating: 166  
      Ship Battles: 71 Overall Battles: 3967
      Ship Frags: 88 Overall Frags: 3753
      Ship Win Rate: 54.93% Overall Win Rate: 56.24%
      Ship Avg Frags: 1.24 Overall Avg Frags: .95
      Ship Wins: 39 Overall Wins: 2231
      Ship Max Frags: 4 Overall Max Frags: 7
      Ship Max Damage: 152874 Aggression: 66